Writer's Support Room - Open Forum Transcripts

Event start time: Tue Apr 19 13:58:00 2005
Event end time: Tue Apr 19 15:07:04 2005


Legend:
Questions from the Audience are presented in red.
Answers by the Speaker are in black.
The Moderator's comments are in blue.

mel boring Join us this afternoon in the AUDITORIUM-Scheduled Events Room for an "Open Forum" with Web Editor Mel Boring. Mel has published some 25 magazine articles and stories, as well as eight books for the young readers market. He taught writing for 18 years, while being home husband and parent to two of his four children, and doing his own writing. He welcomes your questions on time management, getting started, writer's block, marketing, writing rights, writing earnings, or anything else you'd like to discuss. Bring your QUESTIONS to this open forum-in five minutes.
mel boring The Tuesday afternoon "Open Forum" will begin promptly at 4 Atlantic/CANADA, 3 p.m. Eastern, 2 p.m. Central, 1 p.m. Mountain, and noon Pacific. While you wait for the "Open Forum" to start, feel free to use your ASK A QUESTION button RIGHT BETWEEN THE YELLOW "MAP" AND THE RED QUESTION MARK IN ICHAT to post some questions for the discussion group-two minutes from now.
mel boring Good afternoon! Welcome to this Tuesday afternoon's "Open Forum" session. I'm your moderator, Mel Boring, and the Web Editor for this site. We're back for an informal time of answering any questions you might like to ask, on any subject. So feel free to ask what's on your mind--and I'll tell you what's on mine! First, please read these announcements, then we'll get started.
mel boring IMPORTANT INSTRUCTIONS: Send questions you'd like answered or discussed by using your "Ask a Question" icon/button. (It looks like a thought bubble icon, RIGHT NEXT TO THE RED QUESTION MARK.) The moderator (me, Mel Boring) will post the questions one at a time in the chat room and do my best to answer them. Also note: If you want to make it possible to ask the longest question you can, first type "/ask" (without the quotation marks), then leave one space after the end of "ask", then type as many characters of your question as you can. If your question is not complete, send the second part next, then if necessary the third, etc.
mel boring WARNING: If you don't post anything at all, SOME of you will be bounced off the system in 15 minutes. TO PREVENT THIS, type something (either a question to the moderator or even a private message) every 15 minutes to stay active and remain online.
mel boring RIGHT off the bat, GOOD NEWS from lisalisa:...
lisalisa Some good news: my article on the spirited child now
lisalisa appears on BabyZone.com. I thank a member of my
lisalisa critique group for telling me about this great site!
mel boring CONGRATULATIONS, Lisa! That is GREAT NEWS, and BabyZone.com is a marvelous site that I have sampled from time to time....
mel boring Now, after the Open Forum, I'll make a beeline over there to see YOUR article!
lisalisa Thanks, Mel!
mel boring You are WARMLY WELCOME, and VERY deserving!...
mel boring Lisa Leuck has been many-times published on our ICL Web Site.
mel boring This GOOD NEWS comes from Sonya (ITeechABC): I happily sold an article to WEE ONES this week called "Bonkers For
online in Nov/Dec '06. p.s. You should move to Florida where we've been mowing for a good 2 months now! ;
mel boring That WEE ONES Web Site is a STRONG one, Sonya!...
mel boring CONGRATULATIONS!!!
mel boring Someone was asking what online sites were good to submit to, and THAT is one I'll have to recommend! I can't wait for Nov/Dec to read your "Bonkers for Buttons"--and I LOVE that title, friend!
mel boring Tina Schwartz sent this GOOD NEWS: I have a new book coming out at the end of May
GUIDE FOR THE ENTIRE FAMILY, from Scarecrow Press
mel boring CONGRATULATIONS to Tina!!! She is an ICL Graduate,...
mel boring and VERY GRATEFUL to them for her success....
mel boring This is Tina's SECOND publication, and I've asked her about Scarecrow Press, to increase my own knowledge of publishers....
mel boring I know from its listing in the 2005 BOOK MARKETS FOR CHILDREN'S WRITERS...
mel boring that it offers a royalty contract, and I'm going to find out more about it from Tina. CONGRATULATIONS, Tina, and MANY HAPPY RETURNS!
mel boring Marion Tickner has this GOOD NEWS: ONCE UPON A TIME reprinted one of my ICL articles in their Spring issue. They are reprinting another ICL article in the issue coming out this week. Also, OUAT needs short articles to fill in and they just accepted a short article on why write for magazines. AKA Casey
mel boring Marion, AKA casey at our chats, is a multi-contributor of articles to our ICL Web Site...
mel boring NOW, ONCE UPON A TIME is reprinting them--and that is DOUBLE GOOD NEWS for Marion AND us! CONGRATULATIONS, Marion!
writermom Mel I just wanted to let you know I recieved my contract from ParenLife for an article to be published Jan. 2006.
mel boring ALL kinds of publication you are having, writermom!...
mel boring CONGRATULATIONS to the Nth Degree! We'll be eager to see your article in January 2006!
ladybird39pm how do you get published onICL
mel boring GOOD question, ladybird39pm, and I'm GLAD you asked....
mel boring There are guidelines for submission of articles to us at:...
mel boring http://www.institutechildrenslit.com/rx/wt05/writers_guidelines_12.shtml...
mel boring Go to that site and read the description of what we need, what we pay, and other particulars....
mel boring Submissions for our ICL Web Site are life and breath for it, so I'm always glad to receive them!
sarahvrichard do you know of any good screenwriting courses?
mel boring No, I'm sorry I don't, sarahvrichard, since...
mel boring most of children's writing doesn't involve screenwriting,...
mel boring at least until you get up in the echelons with the likes of Phyllis Reynolds Naylor,...
mel boring who will be our Chat Guest on May 12...
mel boring and who told me this morning that this summer is the filming of one of her novels...
mel boring But sarahvrichards, I would suggest you go to amazon.com,...
mel boring and look for screenwriting BOOKS, since I've known people who learned from BOOKS without taking COURSES....
mel boring BEST of FORTUNE to you; and may an already-published book of yours make it onto the Silver Screen!
caq I recently saw a book packaged nicely with 3 stuffed owls. I have seen many packaged books like this and had often wondered about it. Is this the publishers idea and doing or is it the author’s idea given in the coverletter> (i.e. My idea is to have the book packaged with 3 little owls.)
mel boring It's always the PUBLISHER's idea, caq,...
mel boring and it comes about when a book is EITHER very successful, or they KNOW ahead that it WILL be very successful,...
mel boring so they increase its saleability with the addition of a stuffed animal....
mel boring I think it would not be helpful for an author to suggest it when submitting a...
mel boring manuscript the publisher hasn't even seen, my friend.
mel boring From about a month ago, here's this:
mel boring LizzieGirl sent this information about a child's speech problem that was brought up in Open Forum March 22 (MB:Verbal dyspraxia affects the delivery of a child's speech. The child can be quite intelligent, know what they want to say, fully understand the words they want to say, but be incapable of making the correct or total response.):
where MB could look for info on that speech thing s/he was asking about. I believe the child in THE RESCUE by Nicholas Sparks had it. This child was based on his real-life boy
mel boring THANKS, LizzieGirl! That info used in a book sounds GOOD!
mel boring About our Word of the Forum previously:...
mel boring The meaning of deglutition: dee-glue-TEE-shun: the act or process of swallowing

to swallow.
the act of swallowing or gulping....it is a noun...it seems awkward in a sentence to me.....The deglutition of worms is not easy for a baby bird. ( Is that correct?)
BOTH are
mel boring You are right, and I first ran across this in a poem by Emily Dickenson!...
mel boring So it's an older word, but STILL has meaning....
mel boring TODAY'S Word of the Forum is:...
mel boring luminary: \LOOM-in-airy\...
mel boring Anyone know what it means? It's a noun.
mel boring Here are related questions, one from right here now, and one pre-submitted:...
mel boring JC wants to know: Is it acceptable/ appropriate to pay entry fees for writing contests? Is there a way to screen out "scammers?" Also, if paying an entry fee is legitimate, acceptable, etc., is there an amount that should not be exceeded?
crabby j Is there a standard, aceptable ceiling for fees to enter
crabby j writing contests? A good source for identifying the scams?
mel boring Yes, there ARE fees for writing contests, JC and crabby j....
mel boring But the fee should be REASONABLE, one that covers the contest-giver's costs, withOUT making them wealthy....
mel boring For instance, there's a fee, I THINK, for the ICL contests, and that JUST covers the cost of running the contest....
mel boring Someone please correct me if I'm wrong....
mel boring If a contest charges, say , I would stay away from that contest,...
mel boring because they'll likely running it as a profit-making scheme.
mel boring The only "source" for identifying the scams--unless WE talk about them---...
mel boring is a LARGE fee they might charge.
sarahvrichard do you know of any good critique groups?
mel boring One best way to find those, sarahvrichard,...
mel boring is to go to www.scbwi.org...
mel boring and search that site of the Society of Children's Book Writers and Illustrators for the...
mel boring REGIONAL ADVISORS, and then see if, in their region--or yours--there are critique groups at work.
mel boring There are also critique, online groups at an organization...
mel boring called BOOST4Writers, at, I think: www.boost4writers.com...
mel boring and there you will find very congenial critique groupS, plural, who have been helpful to MANY!
mel boring VN wants to know: What's the difference between "Creative Nonfiction" and "Real Life Fiction?" I find this intriguing when dealing with topics that touch on personal experience.
mel boring And the difference is...
mel boring TAH-DAH!...
mel boring that the FIRST is NONFICTION and the SECOND is FICTION....
mel boring That's the simplest difference. Creative nonfiction is the facts about a subject or situation....
mel boring Real-Life FICTION has the verisimilitude of real life written into a fiction story.
mel boring Ah, here's MORE info on screenwriting, from casey!...
casey Writer's Journal Magazine always has an article on screenwriting. In the latest issue there's an ad. Go to www.hollywooodlitsales.com and click on the sotp sign. Maybe sarah will get more information there.
lisalisa /ask If submitting to the publisher of bi-lingual books, is
lisalisa it always necessary to submit the second language text, or
lisalisa will the publisher just translate it for you?
mel boring I don't know the answer to this one, I'm afraid, lisalisa....
mel boring but I will ASK people here, and I will also find out more before next Tuesday....
mel boring ANYone here know if you need to provice the second-language text if you are submitting a bi-lingual book manuscript? Let me know and I'll pass it on!
mel boring spotslover2 sent this question: For a "how-to" article on using fabric paint, I mentioned magazines as a source of art work. But then I began to worry about copyright issues, so I said to be careful about copying; that is was probably alright to copy one flower out of a picture, but not the whole picture. I figured the "fair
Do you think this is okay, or should I delete all mention of copyright material as a source?
mel boring I would EITHER not mention the copyright issue, spotslover2, OR just delete mention of copyright material....
mel boring It is THEIR responsibility, too, not to infringe copyright, so you might want to just leave it all up to them. OR you could delete mention of copyright material.
mel boring Midge asked this question about clips: If a magazine asks for clips what do you send? How long should the clip be? Is a clip a writing sample? I recently sent a 270-word release to a local newspaper and it was published without revision. It was an interview I did with four students who were involved in a charitable project. The problem is my name wasn't used. Can I use this as a clip? Can a descriptive
be a clip?
mel boring The clip should be of a PUBLISHED piece,JUST ONE page, Midge....
mel boring And if your name isn't on it, that's OK, since the recipient will assume you wrote it...
mel boring But just typing up a description or a character sketch, unpublished, would NOT be considered a clip.
mel boring casey says of that screenwriting Web site:...
casey that should have been stop sign.
mel boring THANKS also to casey for the REAL scoop about the entry fee for ICL contests:...
casey The fee is for unsubscribers - but they receive subscription to Childrens Writer. No charge for subscribers.
mel boring SO for that , you get the CHILDRENS WRITER--one of the BEST and most UP-TO-DATE children's writers' guides I know of!
mel boring Now, about that "luminary":...
spotslover2 A well known person, generally of an intellectual bent.
birdi luminary is a source of light. we purchase luminaries each year to honor our friends and relatives who have died from cancer.
delima-e luminary means ans important person
mel boring You're right, you three! Pope John Paul II was a luminary,...
mel boring for example. AND birdi brought up an IMPORTANT point:..
mel boring "luminary" comes from the Latin "Lumens," for "light."...
mel boring THANKS for your answers, friends!
tolkienlvr Mel, for nonfic. mags that seek articles for various ages
tolkienlvr (ie. 3-6 yo and 9-12 y.o) is it ok to write 2 articles on
tolkienlvr same topic for the two age groups and submit both, so editor
tolkienlvr can decide which is the greater need for mag? Or no? Thx. :)
mel boring tolkienlvr (whose Username we LOVE)...
mel boring It is OK, but I wouldn't submit both to the SAME editor...
mel boring What I'd suggest is that you submit one to THAT editor, and the other to another editor at a DIFFERENT magazine....
mel boring If you give then both to the SAME editor, s/he is bound to compare them,...
mel boring and "pick the best one."...
mel boring So your chances of DOUBLING your fortune will be in submitting them to two different mags.
crabby j What is the specific age group "'tween?"...
crabby j A submission I'm working on asks the writing to be geared to
crabby j the 'tween group...
mel boring I've heard "tweeners" of the "tween" group described as ANY age of children...
mel boring who fall "in between" two "standard" age groups....
mel boring For example, "tween" might refer to those kids who are...
mel boring in between the standard age 7-9 group and the 8-12 group....
mel boring So those "tweeners" might be about 9 and 10....
mel boring That term has risen because the "standard" age groups...
mel boring are "deteriorating," and it's almost as if you're writing for ONE single age now, the 7'ers or the 11'ers or the 15'ers....
mel boring And SOME magazines "specialize" in certain in-between age groups, crabby j....
mel boring By the way, I'll bet you're no more CRABBY than I am BORING! (-:}
latona Once you have won a writing contest, is it a clip, then?
mel boring Yes, latona, MOST DEFINITELY!...
mel boring and you would tell the publisher you send it to about the contest.
doug Mel Tweens are typically the 10-14 yr olds- in between childhood and full blown adolescence
mel boring THANKS, doug! That makes sense!
casey ladybird39pm is trying to ask a question.
casey ladybird39 pm is asking about contests. If you look in the back of the 2005 Magazine Market for Children's Writers I noticed the contest fee is from -
mel boring The sounds very reasonable, and maybe the contest is to cover a WIDER range of publishing/publicizing the contest....
mel boring So the wouldn't automatically be out of line, but I'd want to know WHY it is that much, ladybird39.
doug Mel-wouldn't it be best to send a query with the topic and ASK which age group the editor wants?
mel boring Yes, it WOULD be, doug. And if they give it in a marketing guide,...
mel boring you can find it there. But if it isn't given, or it's called the "in betweener" or "tweens," then YES, writing and asking would be a GOOD IDEA.
ekuffmom A true incedent turned into a story, is this nonfiction?
mel boring A STORY is, technically, FICTION, ekuffmom....
mel boring That is part of the very definition of STORY....
mel boring So if a true incident is turned into a STORY, then it is NOT nonfiction....
mel boring Now, SOMEtimes, people call articles "stories," though they are technically articles....
mel boring But if you take a true incident, fictionalize it, turning it into a STORY, then it is FICTION.
mel boring I don't know these authors, but spotslover 2 offers this suggestion:...
spotslover2 Good examples of creative non-fiction are books by Jacqueline Briggs Martin or Kathleen Karr.
latona Yippee!
mel boring YIPPEE, too, latona!
caq Mel, you told tolkienlvr to send the article to two different magazines. Is that because they are for two different age groups, even though the same article redone? It would be like to different articles then? Could you clarify this for us?
mel boring Yes, it's because they are for two different age groups.
dell On June 11, 2005, the 9th Annual Upstate NY Conference for Writers and Illustrators presents WHAT A TRIP AMBER BROWN dedicated to the memory of Paula Danziger. This is a wonderful opportunity to hear editors and authors speak about the world of children's writing. For more info and/or to register, check out the web site : http://www.scbwi-upny.org/home/home.php
mel boring THANKS, dell!...
mel boring I would HIGHLY RECOMMEND that conference,...
mel boring even though this is the first I've known about it....
mel boring But to have known Paula Danziger is ENOUGH to be able to recommend what sounds like a MARVELOUS conference!
crabby j So would Tween and YA more or less overlap grouping-wise?
mel boring Yes, they would, crabby j....
mel boring And in TODAY's market, there is MUCH overlapping....
mel boring About 25 years ago, even, the age groups of 4-6, 7-9, 8-12, 13-15 and 16-19 were VERY definitive and separate....
mel boring But the lines have been blurred nowadays....
mel boring There are MANY YA kids reading ADULT books....
mel boring There are many ADULTS reading picture books...
mel boring So it's a kind of different world.
mel boring Here's an insight:...
spotslover2 The best understanding of creative nonfiction that I've been able to come up with, is that is a factual telling of an event that reads like a story.
ladybird39pm k mel it was for non members the members fee was from southwest writers workshop writerscontest
mel boring That makes sense, ladybird 39pm,...
mel boring that it would cost NONmembers more....
mel boring And that sounds very reasonable.
ladybird39pm sorry that was 45.Skipping Stones Awards entry free is
mel boring THANKS for the update!
spotslover2 Remember also that SCBWI is sponsoring an Amber Brown scholarship in Paula's honor. Check the SCBWI website for details.
doug Mel the query ques I had was for the article (tolkienlvr) idea with two age groups- the tween response was for a different ques.
mel boring THANKS, doug, for clarifying that!
mel boring I've had questions about ICL's Beyond the Basics writing course....
mel boring and I can say that what it allows you to do is...
mel boring work on ONE piece for MORE than one assignment,...
mel boring in order to bring it to more saleability....
mel boring I'm sure some of you here have taken that Beyond the Basics Course. Would you like to comment on it, if you have?
mel boring I mentioned that on May 12, Phyllis Reynolds Naylor, whose novel SHILOH, won a Newbery Medal,...
mel boring will be our Chat Guest. Phyllis told me this morning in an e-mail the number of REJECTIONS that she's received....
mel boring Want to guess how many before I tell you?
soradina I've taken the Beyond the Basics writing for magazines
soradina and it does allow the student to concentrate more on a
soradina particular aspect of writing -- say revision or marketing.
mel boring THANKS, soradina!
spotslover2 My instructor is helping dig down to a more emotional level in my characters, so I would say the course is being helpful.
mel boring Thank you, too, spotslover2!
mel boring Here is how many rejections Phyllis Reynolds Naylor has received:...
mel boring 10,443 rejection slips!
mel boring She has written since 1960.
mel boring Isn't that an AMAZING number?
spotslover2 So we're still pikers, huh Mel?
mel boring YUP!
ladybird39pm I have taken that course about 10 yrs ago. I learned so much as I knew nothng of writing . I also took "Writing for Children and Teenagers which broadened my scope
mel boring THANK YOU, ladybird39pm!
mel boring I must stop now, THANK YOU ALL for being here, and what you have done for MY LIFE AND WRITING today, friends!
caq Gee, Mel, I have 10,441 rejection letters to go to catch up!
brenbo Phyllis has the patience of a saint!
mel boring You are RIGHT, brenbo, and we'll hear her talk about rejections on May 12....
mel boring BYE for now!@

Return to Open Forum Transcripts